[IPython-dev] Re: Changes to Notebook Format

Hans Meine hans_meine at gmx.net
Wed Aug 3 04:26:57 CDT 2005


On Wednesday 03 August 2005 07:13, Robert Kern wrote:
> Any interleaving of stdout and stderr is an accident.
This is an extreme point of view. ;-)

> The whole point of 
> having two different streams is that they can be handled separately and
> piped to two different locations.
I agree.

> stderr messages need to be written 
> with that in mind for any piece of code.
Right, but..

> Usually, they are, [...]
..I don't agree 100% here.

And it really *can* be misleading if the "order" is wrong (i.e. not 
chronological) - people are just too used to it from e.g. system shells.

It's still a feature in my perspective that's not too unimportant and I don't 
see why it "complicates document generation".  Just because there is not 
maximally one error, one output cell belonging to one input, but an ordered 
alternating sequence?

Greetings,
  Hans




More information about the IPython-dev mailing list