[Numpy-discussion] Numeric3

Travis Oliphant oliphant at ee.byu.edu
Fri Feb 4 14:32:06 CST 2005


>> O.K.   I can see that there are several out there who belive that 
>> SciPy is sufficiently hard to install that they are concerned about 
>> requiring it for their math-using packages (despite the provided 
>> binary distributions, and the work that continues on making it easier 
>> to install).   I'm
>
> [...]
> This sort of leads back to the original point, that is, putting 
> something in the Python Standard Library. I suspect that for most 
> scientists and engineers if they have to install anything extra at all 
> to use arrays practially, they really don't care if it is in the core 
> or not. The current Numeric (or numarray) is a fairly straightforward 
> install now and if the issue is having users avoid this extra install, 
> putting a reduced functionality array package in the core is not going 
> to address this issue. On the other hand, it is likely to have the 
> general Python community more likely to use arrays as an interchange 
> format, which is a separate benefit (a point I stressed at the last 
> scipy conference).
>
As Perry suggested, I personally don't care whether it is in the Python 
core or not.  The only reason I ever wanted to put it into the core is 
because of the PIL.  When I asked the creator of the PIL, why he did not 
use Numeric Python, his response was that it wasn't in the core.    
Right now, I think we would benefit if the basic multidimensional array 
object were in the core.  It would be nicer if we could agree on how 
basic operations were to behave so math could be done with them, and put 
that in there as well.

Perry makes a great point about the benefit of using arrays as an 
interchange format...  There are people out there who use the array  
object in Python for just that.   It would be great if there was one 
multidimensional array object used by the entire Python community for 
applications requiring such a structure, but it wouldn't remove the need 
for "more stuff" to do science and so my interest in getting such an 
object into the Python core has waned considerably over the years. 

I'm more interested now in uniting a fractured community (or at least 
making interoperability easier). 

-Travis









More information about the Numpy-discussion mailing list