[Numpy-discussion] arctan2 with complex args
David Goldsmith
David.L.Goldsmith@noaa....
Sun Apr 29 12:11:41 CDT 2007
I'll take a stab at this one; if I miss the mark, people, please chime in.
What's "strange" here is not numpy's behavior but octave's (IMO).
Remember that, over R, arctan is used in two different ways: one is
simply as a map from (-inf, inf) -> (-pi/2,pi/2) - here, let's call that
invtan; the other is as a means to determine "the angle" (conventionally
taken to be between -pi and pi) of a point in the plane - but since, for
example, tan(pi/4) = tan(-3pi/4) (and in general tan(x) = tan(x-pi)) to
uniquely determine said angle, we need to keep track of and take into
account the quadrant in which the point lies; this is (the only reason)
why arctan2 is a function of two arguments, one representing the
abscissa, the other the ordinate of the point. But when the argument is
complex (arctan2, as the inverse of the tangent function, *is* a valid
function on C), this geometric use no longer makes sense, so there's
really no reason to implement arctan2(z,w), z, w complex. If for some
reason, e.g., uniformity of algorithmic expression - I don't see any
(simple) way to preserve uniformity of code expression - as near as I
can tell, you're going to have to implement an if/else if you need to
allow for the invtan of two complex arguments - you need to handle
arctan2(z,w), implement it as arctan(w/z):
>>> import numpy
>>> numpy.arctan(1j/1j)
(0.78539816339744828+0j)
DG
lorenzo bolla wrote:
> Weird behaviour with arctan2(complex,complex).
> Take a look at this:
>
> In [11]: numpy.arctan2(1.,1.)
> Out[11]: 0.785398163397
>
> In [12]: numpy.arctan2(1j,1j)
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
> exceptions.AttributeError Traceback (most
> recent call last)
>
> AttributeError: 'complex' object has no attribute 'arctan2'
>
> same error for:
>
> In [13]: numpy.arctan2(1j,1.)
> In [14]: numpy.arctan2(1.,1j)
>
> But arctan2 is defined for complex arguments, as far as Octave knows :-) :
>
> octave:7> atan2(1,1)
> ans = 0.78540
> octave:8> atan2(1j,1j)
> ans = 0
> octave:9> atan2(1j,1)
> ans = 0
> octave:10> atan2(1,1j)
> ans = 1.5708
>
> bug or wanted behaviour?
> Lorenzo.
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> _______________________________________________
> Numpy-discussion mailing list
> Numpy-discussion@scipy.org
> http://projects.scipy.org/mailman/listinfo/numpy-discussion
>
More information about the Numpy-discussion
mailing list