[Numpy-discussion] Moving away from svn ?

Ondrej Certik ondrej@certik...
Fri Jan 4 08:16:10 CST 2008


> Imagine the pain in the other direction, which was my experience :) I
> actually did not believe at first that it was so bad, and thought I was
> doing something wrong. At least, it certainly convinced me that SVN was
> not easier than DVCS.

It would made me sick. :)

> I am not familiar with sympy: you are not using trac at all ? Also, how

We use googlecode:

http://code.google.com/p/sympy/

it works nice for us.

> did you convert the svn history ?

using the mercurial extension. Kirill submitted some patches, so that
also branches are converted
and tags too.

> I like the mercurial's way of showing branches and co; bzr does not have
> anything like that out of the box (there are separate projects to show
> sources; there is also launchpad of course, but since it is not open
> source, I do not even consider it for numpy/scipy).
>
> On the other hand, the bzr community is more user-friendly: the tool is
> easier to use I think, the graphical tools are more advanced, at least
> from my experience.

I never used bzr, so I cannot judge.

> > We were basically only deciding between git and Mercurial, but we
> > chose mercurial, because
> >
> > * we are python guys and Mercurial is in python+C, very nicely written
> > and they accept patches (Kirill, one sympy developer, has posted
> > several already, to implement features he was missing - he used to use
> > darcs before)
> > * Sage uses it
> For some time, the big problem of bzr was speed. But bzr accomplished
> quite a lot the last year: the first time I used mercurial, the speed
> difference was obvious; it is not so true anymore (they 'feel' the same,
> basically, but I have not used mercurial extensively, at least compared
> to bzr).
>
> So I think it really boils down to the difficulty of the transition, the
> availability of third party tools (and also the tool used by other
> projects similar to numpy, as you mentionned).

I know that bzr is used by Canonical, but I think socially, you should
choose either
mercurial or git. Those are imho the most widespread DVCS.

As I said, Mercurial being Python+C was very important for us,
so that we can easily fix bugs and implement new functionality in mercurial.

Also the commands of mercurial are very similar to svn.


Ondrej


More information about the Numpy-discussion mailing list