[SciPy-dev] [matplotlib-devel] [Numpy-discussion] Announcing toydist, improving distribution and packaging situation

Nathaniel Smith njs@pobox....
Sun Jan 3 05:05:54 CST 2010


On Tue, Dec 29, 2009 at 6:34 AM, David Cournapeau <cournape@gmail.com> wrote:
> Buildout, virtualenv all work by sandboxing from the system python:
> each of them do not see each other, which may be useful for
> development, but as a deployment solution to the casual user who may
> not be familiar with python, it is useless. A scientist who installs
> numpy, scipy, etc... to try things out want to have everything
> available in one python interpreter, and does not want to jump to
> different virtualenvs and whatnot to try different packages.

What I do -- and documented for people in my lab to do -- is set up
one virtualenv in my user account, and use it as my default python. (I
'activate' it from my login scripts.) The advantage of this is that
easy_install (or pip) just works, without any hassle about permissions
etc. This should be easier, but I think the basic approach is sound.
"Integration with the package system" is useless; the advantage of
distribution packages is that distributions can provide a single
coherent system with consistent version numbers across all packages,
etc., and the only way to "integrate" with that is to, well, get the
packages into the distribution.

On another note, I hope toydist will provide a "source prepare" step,
that allows arbitrary code to be run on the source tree. (For, e.g.,
cython->C conversion, ad-hoc template languages, etc.) IME this is a
very common pain point with distutils; there is just no good way to do
it, and it has to be supported in the distribution utility in order to
get everything right. In particular:
  -- Generated files should never be written to the source tree
itself, but only the build directory
  -- Building from a source checkout should run the "source prepare"
step automatically
  -- Building a source distribution should also run the "source
prepare" step, and stash the results in such a way that when later
building the source distribution, this step can be skipped. This is a
common requirement for user convenience, and necessary if you want to
avoid arbitrary code execution during builds.
And if you just set up the distribution util so that the only place
you can specify arbitrary code execution is in the "source prepare"
step, then even people who know nothing about packaging will
automatically get all of the above right.

Cheers,
-- Nathaniel


More information about the SciPy-Dev mailing list