[SciPy-user] Arrayfns in numpy?

Alan Isaac aisaac@american....
Wed Mar 7 09:14:39 CST 2007


Matthieu Brucher wrote:
> I'm opposed to this as well, interpolation is not linear algebra, it is
> signal processing, and as Souheil said, why not nd-interpolation with
> B-Splines then ?

I am not taking sides on this issue, but I do
take issue with trying to settle it with this
kind of "argument".  A rhetorical question does
not set out the issues.  For example, treating
a rhetorical question as a real question for a
moment, one might respond that a simple 1-d
interpolation would
- find wide use among people who need nothing more
- enhance backward compatibility
- impose minimum maintenance requirements

Again, I am not taking sides on the issue, so I
am in no way suggesting that such points are
decisive.  However opposition that fails to
address such points is hardly decisive either.

My point of reference would be: if it is likely
to drain even modest developer effort away from
core NumPy issues, then it is harmful. Otherwise
it is harmless as long as it introduces no new
dependencies.

Alan Isaac


More information about the SciPy-user mailing list