[SciPy-user] fromimage returns instance instead of numpy array

Zachary Pincus zpincus@stanford....
Wed Oct 10 14:19:48 CDT 2007


> On Tue, 9 Oct 2007, Zachary Pincus apparently wrote:
>> My current solution is a fork of PIL that I made, which
>> rips out basically everything except image IO, and for
>> which I fixed the 16- bit image problems and drastically
>> beefed up the numpy compatibility.  I'd be happy to send
>> this to anyone who desires, or if there was a specific
>> clamor, make it a scikit or something. Is there any
>> interest regarding that either?
>
> Is Pythonware not interested in the fixes?

As far as I can tell there was no interest in any of the patches that  
I put forward (either for simple or larger issues). Stefan seems to  
have had a similar experience.

> IMO, making this available as a SciKit is desirable
> only if the better solution, a fixed PIL, is not
> feasible.

I agree entirely.

The PIL folks said that for PIL 2.0 (is this even real, or is it  
mythical, I do not know) they were re-working the memory model, which  
should ameliorate some of the 16-bit image problems, and will  
probably comply better with the new buffer interface. But I have no  
idea when that might actually be happening, and it sounds like the  
developers aren't interested in addressing the issues in the mean time.

Zach



More information about the SciPy-user mailing list