[Numpy-discussion] the neighbourhood of each element of an array
Fri Feb 23 13:18:48 CST 2007
A Divendres 23 Febrer 2007 17:38, firstname.lastname@example.org escrigué:
> Given a (possibly masked) 2d array x, is there a fast(er) way in Numpy to
> obtain the same result as the following few lines?
> d = 1 # neighbourhood 'radius'
> Nrow = x.shape
> Ncol = x.shape
> y = array([[x[i-d:i+d+1,j-d:j+d+1].ravel() for j in range(d,Ncol-d)] \
> for i in range(d,Nrow-d)])
> What you get is an array containing all the elements in a neighbourhood for
> each element, disregarding the edges to avoid out-of-range problems. The
> code above becomes quite slow for e.g. a 2000x2000 array. Does anyone know
> a better approach?
Well, it seems that copying data here is taking most of the CPU. Perhaps you
may want to try getting *references* to the original slices better. For
example, if rd = 2+d, you can write:
# The next is for an array of references to *views* of neighborgs
y = numpy.empty((Nrow-2*d, Ncol-2*d), dtype='object')
for i in xrange(0, Nrow-2*d):
x2 = x[i:i+rd] # Get a view of the first dimension slice
for j in xrange(0, Ncol-2*d):
y[i, j] = x2[:,j:j+rd].ravel()
which is a 1.34x (on my machine) faster than your current approach.
If you want more speed, you may want to not .ravel() in the new array creation
time (you can always use .ravel() when you are going to use the data). The
removal of the .ravel() call makes the above function 2.56x faster.
Finally, if your machine has an x86 architecture, you can also take advantge
of Psyco so as to accelerate a bit more. With Psyco and not raveling, you can
get up to 3x better times than your original approach (without using Psyco).
Of course, more speed-ups could be possible by using Pyrex or any other easy
method for doing C-extensions.
I'm attaching a small benchmark, and here are the results for my machine:
ref time--> 3.021
views (ravel) time--> 2.258 speed-up--> 1.34
views (no ravel) time--> 1.179 speed-up--> 2.56
and if we use psyco:
ref time--> 2.368
views (ravel) time--> 1.636 speed-up--> 1.45
views (no ravel) time--> 0.935 speed-up--> 2.53
>0,0< Francesc Altet http://www.carabos.com/
V V Cárabos Coop. V. Enjoy Data
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Size: 1675 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://projects.scipy.org/pipermail/numpy-discussion/attachments/20070223/762867a5/attachment.bin
More information about the Numpy-discussion