[SciPy-user] Simple plot problem

Guilherme P. de Freitas guilherme@gpfreitas....
Tue Feb 17 04:56:08 CST 2009

Hi again, Gael. I forgot to comment on the documentation.

> I would interested in figuring out what posed problem in the
> documentation, and how things could be improved. The trick is to create
> arrays to evaluate the functions on: x and y. For a surface, you need to
> create a 2D array, in other words a grid of x and y varying in the 2
> directions. This is what the mgrid function does. Maybe a note about
> mgrid in the documentation relative to plotting surface could help?

The use of mgrid was not the puzzle. The puzzle was why I got the
shrinked object in the plot3d. As for the documentation, it would be
nice in the documentation of the plot3d function to have specified
what is a valid input. As far as I know, here's the official
documentation of the mlab.plot3d function:


And it just says "Draws lines between points". I think something
like "x, y and z must be arrays of the same shape" would help a lot.
I figured that out by trial and error (the error messages are
informative), but it took a while, and given that I had a problem, I
thought I was doing something wrong (I'm still not sure, because I
still have the "shrinking" problem), and the documentation did not
help in figuring out what was wrong.

In part the documentation did not help be because a specification of
valid input was not available, but also in part because there isn't
a single *simple* example of Mlab worked out. I suppose plotting
simple (x,y) |-> z function is probably not the intended use of
Mlab, but given the lack of other 3d plotting alternatives in
Python, it can be very useful.

Guilherme P. de Freitas

More information about the SciPy-user mailing list